Gernie NYC is a men's footwear brand built around handcrafted leather sneakers, and the 22's Penny Leather Low Top is one of its signature styles — a penny-loafer-inspired sneaker made with genuine leather. We reviewed the official product listing to break down the materials, construction, sizing, and pricing.
This shoe blends the classic penny loafer silhouette with a low-top sneaker sole, aimed at buyers who want a dressier alternative to a standard casual sneaker. According to the official listing, it's handcrafted by skilled artisans in Brazil, giving it an artisanal, small-batch production story rather than a mass-manufactured sneaker feel. The penny-strap detail across the vamp is a nod to traditional loafer design, while the low-profile rubber-soled base keeps the silhouette closer to a sneaker than a formal dress shoe. The brand's Brazilian manufacturing base is worth highlighting on its own — Brazil has a long-established shoemaking industry known for skilled leatherwork at a more accessible price point than some European ateliers, which may help explain how Gernie NYC delivers full-grain leather construction and handcrafted details at $225 rather than the $400-plus range often seen with comparable Italian-made leather sneakers.
Per the product page, the sneaker is built with:
The removable footbed is a particularly practical detail for anyone who wears orthotics or prefers a specific insole — it means the shoe can be adjusted for individual comfort rather than being locked into a single fixed footbed. Combined with the genuine calf leather lining, this suggests the brand is targeting buyers who plan to wear the shoe for extended periods, not just as an occasional dress-up piece.
The 22's Penny Leather Low Top is offered in six leather and color combinations:
The "Croco" options use an embossed crocodile-style texture, giving buyers a choice between smooth Napa or Garda leather for a cleaner look, or a textured croc-embossed leather for a bolder statement shoe. All six colorways are available across a full size run from 7 to 13, including half sizes. The tan croco colorway in particular stands out as a warmer-toned option for buyers who want something more distinctive than the more common black and navy choices.
Sizes run from 7 through 13, including half sizes (7, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10, 10.5, 11, 11.5, 12, 13), giving a reasonably wide range for most standard adult men's shoe sizes. As with any leather shoe brand, if you're unfamiliar with Gernie NYC's specific fit, it's worth checking whether the brand publishes a size chart or fit notes (for example, whether the shoe runs true to size or narrow) before ordering, since leather penny-loafer-style sneakers can sometimes fit differently than athletic sneakers. Because the footbed is removable and fully padded, minor fit adjustments can potentially be made with insoles if a size runs slightly large.
At the time of this review, the 22's Penny Leather Low Top was priced at $225.00 across every color and size combination, so the leather choice (Napa, Garda, or Croco) does not affect the price. This puts it in the premium leather sneaker category, priced closer to designer penny loafers than mass-market sneakers, which lines up with the handcrafted Brazilian construction and genuine leather materials used throughout.
Because this shoe splits the difference between a loafer and a sneaker, it pairs naturally with chinos, tailored trousers, or dark denim for a smart-casual look, and the low sole profile keeps it from looking overly formal with more relaxed outfits. The genuine leather construction means it will benefit from standard leather-shoe care — occasional conditioning and avoiding prolonged exposure to water — to keep the Napa, Garda, or croco-embossed finish looking sharp over time.
This sneaker is aimed at men who want a smart-casual shoe that can bridge the gap between a loafer and a sneaker — dressy enough for business-casual settings but with a lower-profile, more comfortable sole than a traditional dress shoe. The removable footbed and padded construction make it a reasonable option for people who are on their feet for extended periods but still need to look polished. Given the $225 price point, it's best suited to buyers specifically looking to invest in a genuine leather shoe with a distinctive silhouette rather than shoppers comparing purely on price against synthetic sneakers.
Gernie NYC's 22's Penny Leather Low Top offers a handcrafted, Brazilian-made take on the penny loafer sneaker hybrid, with genuine Napa, Garda, or croco-embossed leather uppers, a padded and removable footbed, and a lightweight 3/4-inch elevated sole. Priced at $225 across all six colorways and full-size run, it's a solid option for anyone looking for a distinctive leather sneaker that stands apart from typical athletic or canvas options. Check the official Gernie NYC site for current color and size availability before ordering.
#GernieNYC #PennyLoafer #LeatherSneakers #MensFootwear #HandcraftedShoes #MensStyle #LowTopSneakers #ItalianStyleFootwear
